Skip navigation

No return to native forest logging

1.png

As we get closer to the November state election, the conservative parties have announced policies which will have a direct negative impact on nature and biodiversity if they are implemented.

 

The Liberal/ National Coalition have announced that they will restart native timber ‘processing’ from forest management and double the area of public land burnt each year through fuel reduction programs.

 

One Nation has promised to resume native timber logging if it wins the state election, but has not said how the policy would be funded or achieved.

 

Please sign this open letter to the Liberals and Nationals outlining why burning targets and reopening native forests to commercial timber removal will be bad for nature.

 

Who's signing

500 Signatures

26 Signatures

Will you sign?

Jess Wilson

Leader of the Opposition

 

Melina Bath

Shadow Minister for Public Land Management 

 

Ms Wilson and Ms Bath,

 

I write to express my alarm at the announcement by the Victorian Liberal-National Coalition to revive native forest harvesting and timber processing if elected in the November 2026 state election.

 

We all want Victoria’s regional communities to be safer from bushfires and to prosper socially and economically. 98% of Australians also think it's important to prevent extinctions of plants and animals. Your proposed forest management policy will undermine both of these priorities.

 

The majority of Victorians want our unique forests and wildlife kept safe for future generations, not exploited further.

 

Many decades of native forest logging cost taxpayers in Victoria more than a billion dollars. Hundreds of millions have been spent on transition following the cessation of native forest logging in 2023. Reopening native forest logging would be bad for the environment and would be a significant act of poor economic management.

 

Climate change is increasing bushfire risk and driving worsening fire seasons. This fact is consistent with mainstream scientific consensus and the views of every firefighting agency in Australia. Mature forests protect us all from worsening climate change by drawing down and storing carbon. Victoria’s forests store more carbon than anywhere else in the world: logging them again would destroy one of our best solutions to halt escalating climate change.

 

Furthermore, there is no scientific evidence that “forests left unmanaged burn harder and recover more slowly” – but there is plenty of documented and emerging evidence to the contrary. Industrial thinning and broad-scale planned burning may actually make bushfire risks worse by creating forests that are more flammable. This heightened flammability would last well beyond this political cycle, leaving regional communities at a heightened level of risk for decades. Perpetuating misinformation about “hazardous fuel loads”, rather than listening to science, is dangerous. Burning large areas to achieve hectare targets is a particularly dangerous path, because it also runs the risk of ‘burning to meet targets’ rather than ‘burning to meet outcomes’, and pushes land managers to work in conditions not optimal for safe operations. 

 

There is one positive aspect of your policy worth noting. I applaud your investment in a $4.41 million bushfire detection camera network across 18 locations in eastern and western Victoria. Forest Fire Management Victoria’s on-the-ground staff already effectively respond to suppress fires early. FFMVic successfully contained 83% of bushfires on first response – and 92% of the fires were kept under 5 hectares in size. Investing in new technology and providing robust resourcing for these on-the-ground crews  – including more remote areas firefighters –  to rapidly respond to new ignitions would be a much better use of public money than reviving a dead industry. Together, we can protect both regional communities and our recovering native forests from major bushfires.

 

A real pathway to ‘healthy forests’ would involve pro-actively re-planting logged sites that have failed to regenerate across Victoria. Investing in public land management, including deer and weed management, would assist this regeneration process and allow recovering forests to reach a mature forest structure that is both most resilient to bushfire and most appropriate for habitat. It is essential that forests are pro-actively protected from more disturbance, like bushfires and logging, during this recovery process. Thinning 5,000 hectares of recovering forests will produce the exact opposite of recovery and could directly cause the extinction of unique Australian wildlife.

 

The Victorian bush was not “locked up”, but was instead ravaged by the industrial logging conducted by consecutive previous governments. These forests need decades to begin to recover. Hollows that can provide wildlife habitat can take over 100-120 years to form. Valuable mature forests were logged en-masse in the last few years of the logging industry to meet outdated supply agreements. Re-growth of logged areas has also systematically failed (at least 20% of logged mountain ash has been reduced to paddocks full of weeds). By allowing industrial thinning in remaining forests, you will be robbing Victoria of the opportunity to ever re-establish ‘healthy forests.’

 

Positive policy that would support your goals of processing local timber “with revenue to be reinvested locally” could involve integrating farm forestry into existing agricultural landscapes (simultaneously supporting farmers to diversify their income) and designing programs that enable local workers and hobbyists to continue to work with timber that has been recovered during operations already conducted, outside of our over-exploited public land estate. These initiatives would honour the history and identity of these regions and promote the responsible use of timber, without endangering community safety or sacrificing our remaining wildlife by mistreating forest reserves.

 

Re-opening native forest logging, of any kind, is guaranteed to be extremely fraught and unlikely to deliver job security. Conversely, policies that proactively protect and re-plant forests on public land and establish native species on under-utilised private land could create thousands of jobs.

 

I urge you to reconsider this unscientific and deeply unpopular policy.

Read More